- Klutzy (Quauntonaut)
- Herbert (Herbert P. Bear)
- G (Poisoon140)
- Jet Pack Guy (Worldwwe)
- Rookie (King Eraser)
- Dot (Gummyz1315)
- Director (123kitten2)
- Orange secret agent puffle (Fan made by me) (Guinydyl)
- Green secret agent Puffle (fan made by me) (NLG343)
- Red secret agent Puffle (fan made by me) (Speed578)
- Blue secret agent Puffle (fan made by me) (ClubPenguinMineCraft)
- Rainbow secret agent Puffle (fan made by me) (Crazycool20)
- Yellow secret agent Puffle (fan made by me) (Club Penguin Lover1)
- brown secret agent Puffle (fan made by me) (SlyClaws)
- black secret agent Puffle (fan made by me) (Ninja Penguins)
- White secret agent Puffle (fan made by me) (Puffles206)
- Secret agent Pookie (fan made by me) (Ph1n3a5and77)
(if you change your mind, you can pick another character)